Criminal Litigation · Crim 2

Available

Types of Arrest, Reasonable Suspicion, and Necessity of Arrest

There are three primary categories for justifying an arrest:

  1. Arrest without a warrant
  2. Arrest with a warrant
  3. To prevent breach of the peace

Arrest without a warrant

Under PACE 1984, s.24, a constable may arrest without warrant a person who:

  • is about to commit an offence;
  • is committing an offence;
  • is reasonably suspected of being about to commit an offence;
  • is reasonably suspected of committing an offence; or
  • where an offence has been committed, is guilty or reasonably suspected of being guilty of it.

The power is discretionary and is subject to the separate necessity test.

Reasonable suspicion

Where the power to arrest depends on suspicion, there is a two-part test:

TestQuestion
SubjectiveDid the officer genuinely suspect the person?
ObjectiveWere there reasonable, objective grounds for that suspicion based on the facts and information known to the officer?

Under Code G, para. 2.3A, there must be reasonable and objective grounds based on known facts and information.

Key points

  • Suspicion is assessed using what the officer knew or perceived at the time.
  • Hindsight is not relevant.
  • Suspicion requires less evidence than a prima facie case.
  • The information supporting suspicion does not necessarily have to be admissible evidence.
  • It is not necessary to identify the precise offence, but the facts must point towards some form of offence.

The necessity test

Even where a power of arrest exists, the officer must have reasonable grounds for believing that arrest is necessary.

Under PACE 1984, s.24(5), arrest may be necessary:

  • to establish the person's name where it cannot readily be ascertained or there are reasonable grounds for doubting the name given;
  • to establish the person's address on the same basis;
  • to prevent the person:
  • causing physical injury to themselves or another;
  • suffering physical injury;
  • causing loss of or damage to property;
  • committing an offence against public decency; or
  • causing an unlawful obstruction of the highway;
  • to protect a child or other vulnerable person;
  • to allow the prompt and effective investigation of the offence or the person's conduct; or
  • to prevent the prosecution being hindered by the person's disappearance.

Arrest with a warrant

Magistrates’ Court Warrants

Under MCA 1980, s.1, a warrant may be issued where a person has, or is suspected of having, committed an offence. For a person aged 18 or over: the offence must be indictable; or punishable with imprisonment; or the person’s address is not sufficiently established for a summons.

Failure to Attend

Failure to answer a summons: the magistrates’ court may issue an arrest warrant under MCA 1980, s.13. Failure to surrender to bail: arrest is governed by Bail Act 1976, s.7.

Crown Court Warrants

Under Senior Courts Act 1981, s.80(2), the Crown Court may issue a warrant where: an indictment has been signed but D has not been sent for trial; or D has entered into a recognizance to attend and fails to do so.

Warrants Endorsed for Bail

A warrant may be endorsed for bail. If the required sureties are provided, D may be released and required to attend court at the specified time.

Arrest to prevent a breach of the peace

A person may arrest where: a breach of the peace occurs in their presence; they reasonably believe one will occur in the immediate future; or a breach has occurred and they reasonably believe a further breach is threatened.

The belief must be reasonable in light of the circumstances perceived at the time.